Most water heater problems come down to a short list of parts, and many can be fixed without replacing the tank. The plumber diagnoses the cause first and tells you whether a repair makes sense for the age of the unit.
Common problems and causes
- No hot water on a gas unit: failed thermocouple or flame sensor, bad gas valve, or a pilot blown out by a draft.
- No hot water on an electric unit: tripped high-limit switch, burned-out heating element or failed thermostat.
- Hot water runs out fast: a broken dip tube or a tank half-full of sediment.
- Popping or rumbling: sediment on the bottom of the tank boiling as the burner heats it.
- Rusty or smelly water: a spent anode rod.
- Water around the base: could be a loose fitting or the relief valve, or the tank itself.
Repair or replace?
A tank-style heater usually lasts 8 to 12 years, less where the water is hard. If yours is past that range and the tank itself is leaking, replacement is the honest answer. If it is younger and the problem is a part, a repair is usually the better value. Tankless units can run 20 years with yearly descaling, so repairs on them almost always make sense.